Skip to content
← All articles
Home Services

How to compare electricity plans in a deregulated state

Learn how fixed, variable and indexed electricity rates differ, how to read a plan's facts label, and how to compare offers using one household's monthly usage.

A young woman smiling and gesturing toward documents on a wooden desk while speaking with an older man in an office.

In a state that allows retail electricity choice, you can buy your supply from a competitive provider while the local utility keeps delivering power and maintaining the lines. The provider sets the price per kilowatt-hour (kWh) for the energy you use and may add monthly fees, while the utility's delivery charges appear on the same bill and are usually the same whichever supplier you choose. Comparing plans therefore means comparing the supply price and its terms, not the whole bill.

The price structure is where plans differ most. A fixed-rate plan holds the energy price for the contract period, a variable-rate plan can change from one billing cycle to the next, and an indexed plan follows a published wholesale price with a markup. Each structure suits a different tolerance for risk. The right comparison also needs a consistent yardstick, which is why the worked example below applies three plans to the same monthly usage.

Understand the three main rate structures

A fixed-rate plan sets one price per kWh for the full term, commonly six, twelve or twenty-four months. Your energy charge is predictable, which makes budgeting easier, but you may pay more than the market if prices fall during the term. Fixed plans often carry an early termination fee, so check how much leaving early would cost and whether it declines over time.

A variable-rate plan lets the provider adjust the price, usually with notice, and it often has no fixed term. It can be cheap when wholesale prices are low, but the price can rise without a contract change. Ask how often the provider has changed its variable rate in the past and how much notice it gives before a change.

An indexed plan ties the price to a published index, such as a wholesale market benchmark, plus a fixed markup. The bill moves with the market, so it can be lower or higher than a fixed offer. Indexed plans suit households that can absorb month-to-month swings or that expect prices to fall, but they make budgeting harder. Read the formula carefully, since the index, the markup and any caps determine the result.

Read the facts label before you compare

Several states that allow choice require a standardized electricity facts label or disclosure sheet for each offer. The label typically shows the price per kWh at a few usage levels, the length of the contract, the early termination fee, whether the rate is fixed or variable, the renewable content, and any monthly charges. Use the label as the primary source of comparison, because it presents offers in the same format.

Check the label for these items in particular:

  • The all-in price at your usage level, not only the headline rate per kWh
  • Monthly base or service fees that apply whether or not you use power
  • Introductory rates that change after a set number of months
  • Bill credits, and whether they continue only if you stay for the full term
  • Early termination fees and any renewal terms that switch you to a new rate

Where a state does not publish a standard label, ask each provider for the same information in writing. The state public utility commission or the state consumer agency usually publishes a list of licensed suppliers and their offers, which is a useful starting point for comparison.

Worked example: three plans at 1,000 kWh a month

Assume a household uses 1,000 kWh in a month. The rates below are illustrative, not actual prices, and the comparison excludes delivery charges, which are the same for each supplier.

  • Plan A (fixed): 12.0 cents per kWh with a $9.95 monthly fee. Monthly supply cost is $120.00 plus $9.95, or $129.95. Year-one total is $1,559.40.
  • Plan B (variable): 10.5 cents per kWh with no monthly fee. At the current rate the monthly cost is $105.00, and the year-one total is $1,260.00. If the rate rises to 14.0 cents, the same usage costs $140.00 per month, and the year-one total becomes $1,680.00.
  • Plan C (fixed with a credit): 11.0 cents per kWh with a $12.00 monthly fee and a $60.00 bill credit paid as $5.00 each month for twelve months. The effective monthly cost is $117.00 in year one ($110.00 plus $12.00, less $5.00). The year-one total is $1,404.00, but the credit stops if you leave early.

Plan B looks cheapest at the current rate, yet it carries the most risk, because a modest rise in the variable price erases its advantage. Plan C is cheaper than Plan A in year one, but it depends on staying for the full term, so its real cost rises if you switch. The comparison changes with usage: a household that uses 500 kWh pays far less per month, and a fixed monthly fee weighs more heavily on a low-use home. Repeat the calculation with your own bills from the past twelve months, using a range of usage levels.

Watch for delivery charges, taxes and common mistakes

Your utility's delivery charges, meter fees and taxes apply to every supplier, so they do not decide which plan wins. They still matter because they make up part of the total bill and can change when rates are reset. Keep them separate from the supply comparison, and do not assume that a lower supply price guarantees a lower total.

The most common mistake is choosing a plan because of a bill credit or introductory rate without checking the price after the promotion. Another is signing a fixed contract and then moving, which can trigger an early termination fee. People also forget that a contract may renew automatically at a higher rate when it ends, so mark the renewal date. Finally, some households overlook whether they can return to the default utility rate if a supplier fails, which is worth confirming before you switch.

To decide, gather your last twelve bills, calculate the year-one and year-two cost of each offer at your average usage, and check the facts label for fees and termination terms. Confirm the rules for your address with the state public utility commission or consumer office, since choice programs and disclosure requirements vary by state and by utility. If a contract or dispute is complicated, a consumer advocate or an energy consultant can explain the options.