Leasing vs buying a car: how to decide
How a lease payment is built from depreciation and rent charges, how mileage and wear limits work, and how leasing and buying compare over the same period of driving.
Leasing usually costs less per month than buying the same car with a loan, because you pay for the part of the vehicle's value you use up during the lease term rather than the whole price. Buying costs more each month, but at the end you own an asset that can be sold, traded or kept. Whether leasing or buying is cheaper over time depends on how many miles you drive, how long you keep vehicles, how the car holds its value, and whether you value flexibility more than equity.
The decision is mostly arithmetic plus a few judgment calls about how you use a car. Leasing suits people who want a newer vehicle every few years, drive a predictable number of miles and do not want to deal with resale. Buying suits people who drive a lot, keep a car well past the loan, or want no restrictions on modifications and mileage. The comparison below puts both on equal terms.
How a lease payment is built
A lease payment has two main parts. The depreciation charge is the expected drop in value over the term, calculated as the negotiated price of the vehicle, called the capitalized cost, minus the residual value the lessor projects for the end of the term. The second part is the rent charge, which is the financing cost. It is expressed as a money factor, a small decimal. A rough way to compare it with a loan rate is to multiply the money factor by 2,400, which gives an approximate annual percentage rate.
Taxes, registration and fees are added on top. Some states tax the monthly payment and others tax the full price up front, so the total tax bill can look very different from one state to the next. Confirm how your state treats leases with the state department of revenue or the motor vehicle agency.
Mileage and wear limits
Most leases set an annual mileage allowance, commonly somewhere in the range of 10,000 to 15,000 miles, and charge a fixed rate for each mile over it. Choosing a lower allowance lowers the monthly payment but makes overage more likely. Lease contracts also define excessive wear, which can include dents, cracked glass, worn tires and interior damage beyond normal use. Charges for both can be significant at the end of the term, so estimate your annual mileage honestly before you sign.
Leases also restrict modifications and may require the lessor's approval for accessories or tinting. Buying has no such limits, but a purchased car loses value through the same wear and mileage, so the cost shows up later as a lower resale price.
Worked example
Suppose a vehicle has a negotiated price of $35,000 and a projected residual of $21,000 after 36 months. The depreciation charge is $14,000 divided by 36, which is about $389 a month. With a money factor of 0.00125, the rent charge is about $70 a month, calculated on the sum of the capitalized cost and the residual. The monthly payment before tax is therefore close to $459. Assume about $2,000 is due at signing for the acquisition fee and other charges, on top of the 36 monthly payments, which varies by lessor.
Over 36 months the lease payments total roughly $16,500, plus the signing amount, so about $18,500 in total. At the end you return the car and own nothing.
Buying the same vehicle with a loan of $35,000 at 6.5 percent over 36 months gives a payment of roughly $1,070 a month. The total paid is about $38,600, including roughly $3,600 of interest. If the car is worth $21,000 at the end of the term, your net cost over three years is about $17,600, plus any sales tax, registration and insurance differences. The buyer ends with a vehicle worth $21,000. These figures ignore taxes, fees and maintenance, so they are a framework rather than a quote.
Scroll sideways to see the full table →
| Factor | Lease (example) | Buy with loan (example) |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment | About $459 | About $1,070 |
| Cash at signing | About $2,000 | Down payment, if any |
| Total paid over 36 months | About $18,500 | About $38,600 |
| Net cost after the car's value | About $18,500 | About $17,600 |
| Ownership at the end | None | Car worth about $21,000 |
| Mileage limit | Yes, with per-mile charges | No |
Questions to ask before you choose
Ask the dealer for the money factor, the residual value, the capitalized cost and every fee in writing, and check whether the capitalized cost can be negotiated the same way a purchase price can. Ask what the disposition fee is at the end, what the excess mileage charge per mile is, and whether early termination costs apply. Ask whether you can buy the car at the residual value and what that price would be. Lease terms and the federal disclosure rules are set by the Consumer Leasing Act and its regulation, but the details of fees and taxes depend on your state and the lessor, so confirm them in the lease itself.
Write down your typical annual mileage, how many years you keep a car and what you can pay each month, then run the same numbers on a lease and on a loan. If the monthly figure is the deciding factor, compare total cost over the period you expect to keep the car before you choose.