Skip to content
← All articles
Buying a Car

New vs used car: how to compare the total cost

How depreciation, financing, insurance, repairs and taxes change the total cost of a new car versus a used car, with a five-year comparison table.

A man and woman standing on a suburban street between a white car and a silver car, interacting as they look at the vehicles.

Choosing between a new and a used car is often framed as a question of sticker price, but the total cost of owning a car depends on several other factors. Those include how quickly the car loses value, how much interest you pay, what insurance costs and how much you spend on repairs and maintenance. A new car usually costs more at purchase, while a used car reverses many of those differences over the years you keep it.

To compare fairly, estimate the total over the period you plan to keep the car rather than looking at the monthly payment alone. A lower payment can hide a longer loan and more interest, and a low used price can carry repair costs that erase the savings. The sections below explain each cost category and then bring them together in a single comparison.

Depreciation: usually the largest difference

Most new cars lose a substantial share of their value in the first few years, and the steepest drop typically comes early. A used car has already absorbed part of that loss, so its buyer pays less and avoids some of the steepest depreciation. The trade-off is that a used car has less remaining service life and may need repairs sooner.

Depreciation depends on make, model, mileage, condition, trim and market conditions, so the rate varies widely. Estimate the resale value at the point you expect to sell or trade the car, using valuation guides and listings of similar vehicles to see the likely range.

Financing, interest and loan terms

Interest rates differ by lender, credit profile, loan term and whether the manufacturer or dealer offers promotional financing. New cars sometimes qualify for lower promotional rates, while used-car loans often carry higher rates. A longer loan lowers the monthly payment but increases total interest and can leave you owing more than the car is worth for a longer period.

Compare the total interest over the life of the loan rather than only the monthly payment. Getting a preapproved rate from a bank or credit union before visiting a dealer gives you a benchmark. Federal law requires lenders to disclose the annual percentage rate and the total of payments, and state rules may add protections, so confirm the terms in writing before signing.

Insurance, registration and taxes

Insurance premiums depend on the car's value, the cost of its repairs, its safety features and where you live. Newer or more expensive cars usually cost more to insure, particularly for full coverage, because repairs and replacement are costlier. Get quotes for the specific models you are considering, since the difference between two cars can be large.

Sales tax, registration and title fees depend on the state and sometimes on the county or city, and a few states charge additional fees for certain vehicles. Ask the local motor vehicle agency or the state tax authority for the exact figures. Whether sales tax applies to a private-party purchase also differs by state.

Repairs and warranties

A new car usually comes with a manufacturer warranty that covers defects for a set number of years and miles, which reduces repair risk early on. A used car may have a remaining warranty, a certified pre-owned program offered by the manufacturer or no coverage at all. Before buying used, get a vehicle history report and an independent inspection by a qualified mechanic.

Compare the total cost over your ownership period

The table below uses a hypothetical example: a $32,000 new car against a $22,000 three-year-old car, both financed over 60 months, with the new loan at 6 percent and the used loan at 8 percent. Fuel, taxes and fees are excluded because they are similar for both cars or vary by location.

Scroll sideways to see the full table →

Cost over five years (hypothetical)New: $32,000 priceUsed: $22,000 price, 3 years old
Depreciation$16,000$9,000
InterestAbout $5,100About $4,800
Insurance$9,000$7,500
Repairs and maintenance$1,500$4,000
Total$31,600$25,300

In this example the used car saves about $6,300 over five years, but the margin depends on the actual repair history, the interest rate and the insurance quotes. A problem found in an inspection, a higher rate or a more expensive insurance quote could reverse the outcome, while a new car's warranty could reduce its repair line in the early years. Build the table with your own numbers, using quotes, an inspection report and the offers you receive, then compare the totals. Keep the result in front of you while you negotiate, so the decision rests on the full cost rather than on the monthly payment.