Skip to content
← All articles
Business Services

Bookkeeper vs accountant: which one a small business needs

Compare what bookkeepers and accountants do, which tasks suit each, when a small business needs one or both, and what credentials and fees to check before hiring.

A woman wearing a green apron hands a box full of paper receipts to a man sitting at a desk with a laptop in a pottery studio.

A bookkeeper records a business's financial transactions and keeps the books accurate from day to day. An accountant interprets those records, prepares tax returns, advises on decisions such as how to structure the business or how to plan for taxes, and in some cases reviews or audits financial statements. The two roles overlap, and in a small business one person may do both, but they are different jobs, and hiring for the wrong one can leave gaps in the records or in the tax planning.

Most small businesses need bookkeeping every month, and they need an accountant at least once a year for tax filings and often for planning. Whether you need one, the other or both depends on how complex your finances are, how much you do yourself, whether you have employees or inventory, and how much help you want with tax decisions. The comparison below sets out the typical split so you can see which work you are paying for.

What a bookkeeper does

Bookkeeping is the routine recording of money in and out of the business. A bookkeeper typically enters transactions from bank and card accounts, categorizes them, reconciles accounts against statements, tracks accounts payable and receivable, and produces the monthly reports owners use to see cash position and profitability. Good bookkeeping makes the year-end work faster and cheaper, because the records are already accurate.

Bookkeepers vary in training. Some hold professional certifications from bookkeeping associations, and some have worked in accounting departments. States do not license bookkeepers, so the title by itself does not guarantee a specific level of skill. Ask what software the bookkeeper uses, how they keep up with changes, and whether they can produce the reports your lender or investors expect.

What an accountant does

An accountant, and in particular a certified public accountant (CPA), handles the work that depends on professional judgment and on tax or financial reporting rules. This typically includes preparing business and personal tax returns, planning for estimated tax payments, advising on the tax treatment of major purchases or investments, and reviewing the books before the year closes. CPAs are licensed by state boards, which set the education, experience and examination requirements. Other accountants may hold different credentials, so check what the person is licensed to do in your state.

Some accountants provide assurance services, such as reviews or audits of financial statements, which require specific credentials and independence rules. A small business rarely needs an audit, but a lender or investor may ask for a review. If you expect that request, ask the accountant whether they perform reviews and how long they take.

Compare the tasks side by side

The table below shows which tasks usually fall to each role. In practice, the lines are drawn by the engagement, so confirm the scope in writing before work begins.

Scroll sideways to see the full table →

TaskUsually handled byNotes
Recording transactions and categorizing expensesBookkeeperDaily or weekly work that keeps records current
Bank and card reconciliationBookkeeperConfirms the books match the statements
Payables, receivables and invoicing supportBookkeeperTracks what you owe and what customers owe you
Monthly profit and loss and balance sheetBookkeeper, reviewed by accountantAccountant review adds confidence for lenders
Payroll tax filings and year-end formsShared or outsourcedOften handled by a payroll provider
Annual business and personal tax returnsAccountant (CPA)Requires knowledge of current tax law
Tax planning and estimated paymentsAccountant (CPA)Depends on your income pattern and goals
Entity structure and major financial decisionsAccountant (CPA), with an attorney for liability and legal setupAffects liability and tax treatment
Financial statement review or auditAccountant (CPA)Required by some lenders or investors

When you need one, the other or both

A new business with few transactions often starts with a bookkeeper who keeps records tidy and an accountant for the first tax return. As the business grows, with more staff, more bank accounts, inventory or multiple locations, the monthly work increases, and a bookkeeper becomes more valuable. A business with significant tax exposure, such as one with high profits, owner withdrawals to manage or a plan to sell, needs an accountant involved in planning throughout the year rather than only at filing time.

Some small businesses choose one person who does both, particularly where the owner is comfortable with software and the finances are simple. That can work, but make sure the year-end review still happens. A common setup is an outsourced bookkeeper who sends monthly reports to an accountant, who reviews them and prepares the annual return. This arrangement often costs less than hiring a full-time employee and keeps the records checked by a professional.

Mistakes to avoid and what to do next

A common mistake is hiring an accountant to catch up on years of unrecorded transactions. Accountants can do this, but the work is expensive and slow, and it is better handled by a bookkeeper first. Another mistake is expecting a bookkeeper to give tax advice. Ask in advance which questions go to which role, and what happens when a question sits between the two.

Check the fee structure before you hire. Bookkeepers often charge a monthly retainer based on transaction volume, while accountants may charge hourly or by project. Ask for an estimate of the work, the expected monthly cost and any charges for extra services, such as year-end adjustments or responding to a tax notice. Also confirm the person's credentials, insurance and the security of the data they will access.

To decide, list the financial tasks you handle now, the ones you struggle with and the ones you expect to need within the next year. Interview one bookkeeper and one accountant, ask each to explain how they would handle your records, and choose the arrangement that keeps the books current and the tax work accurate. Your state's board of accountancy is the place to check an accountant's license.