Skip to content
← All articles
Business Services

How to compare card payment processing fees

Learn how flat-rate, interchange-plus and tiered card pricing work, and compare what each costs at two sales volumes with a worked example.

A woman shop assistant hands a paper shopping bag to a female customer who is holding a credit card over a payment terminal at a counter.

Card processing fees look simple on a quote, but the same sale can cost very different amounts depending on how the processor prices it. Some providers charge one rate for every card, others pass through the network and issuer costs and add their own markup, and a third group sorts each transaction into tiers that are hard to predict. To compare offers fairly, you need to know which pricing model you are looking at and what the total looks like at the volume your business actually processes.

The fee on a card sale has three parts: the interchange fee paid to the bank that issued the card, the card network assessment, and the processor's own markup. Interchange is set by the card networks, is paid to the issuing bank, and varies with card type, how the card was read and whether the sale was in person or online. The processor's markup is the part you can negotiate or compare. Every pricing model is simply a different way of packaging these three parts into a number on an invoice.

The three common pricing models

A flat-rate model charges one percentage of each sale plus a fixed amount per transaction, regardless of card type. It is easy to read and predictable, which suits small sellers with low monthly volume. The trade-off is that you pay a premium on low-cost cards that the processor would otherwise have charged less for, and the rate is often higher than an interchange-plus quote at larger volumes.

An interchange-plus model passes through the actual interchange and network costs for each transaction and adds a fixed markup on top, usually stated as a percentage and a per-transaction fee. It is more transparent because you can see what is pass-through and what is margin. It suits businesses with steady volume, though the monthly statement is harder to read, and you should confirm whether any monthly, gateway or minimum fees apply.

A tiered model groups transactions into categories such as qualified, mid-qualified and non-qualified, each with its own rate. The categories depend on how the card was read, whether it was keyed in, and other conditions the processor defines. Tiered pricing can look attractive in a quote, but many sales often fall into the higher tiers, and the sorting rules are where the surprises hide. Ask for a sample statement showing how the processor classifies typical sales.

A worked example at two volumes

To see how the models behave, consider two hypothetical sellers, each with an average ticket of 50 dollars. The first processes 10,000 dollars a month in 200 transactions. The second processes 100,000 dollars a month in 2,000 transactions. The figures below are invented for illustration and are not quotes from any provider.

Scroll sideways to see the full table →

Pricing modelTerms assumed10,000 dollars a month100,000 dollars a month
Flat rate2.9 percent plus 0.30 per sale350 dollars3,500 dollars
Interchange-plusBlended interchange 2.1 percent plus 0.10, markup 0.3 percent plus 0.10, 25 dollars monthly fee305 dollars2,825 dollars
TieredBlended 3.2 percent plus 0.30380 dollars3,800 dollars

Under these assumptions, the interchange-plus quote is cheapest at both volumes, and the gap widens at higher volume because the monthly fee and the markup are spread across more sales. The flat-rate and tiered quotes both charge a percentage on the full amount, so their cost grows in step with sales. The ranking would change if an interchange-plus markup were much higher than the flat-rate margin, which is why you should compare the markup itself, not only the headline rate.

Mistakes to avoid when comparing

A common error is comparing only the effective rate on the quote, which often leaves out monthly fees, statement fees, compliance charges, chargeback fees and early termination penalties. Another is ignoring the mix of sales. A business that takes many keyed-in or online sales may pay far more than the in-person rate suggests. Check whether the quote assumes card-present sales, and ask what share of your sales would be charged at each rate.

Also read the contract. Some processors require a multi-year term, charge a fee to close the account, or hold a reserve from your deposits. Equipment may be leased rather than sold, and the lease can cost more over time than the device itself.

What to ask for before you choose

Ask each provider for a statement from a business similar to yours, showing how it classifies sales and what each line costs. Request a written list of every fee, including those that apply only when something goes wrong. Ask whether the rate can change during the contract and how much notice you would receive. Where card acceptance rules, surcharging limits or sales tax treatment depend on your state or industry, confirm the requirements with your card network, your processor and a qualified accountant.

What to do next

Pull three recent monthly statements from your current provider and sort your sales by card type and channel. Then request a quote from two or three providers using those exact figures. The cheapest total at your real volume is the answer, and the option that is easiest to audit is usually the safer choice over time.